Name: They're Real! Magnet Extreme Lengthening Mascara
Brand: benefit
Rating: 2.2 (25 reviews)

They're Real! Magnet Extreme Lengthening Mascara

The whisper

Extreme length marred by a frustrating tendency to flake

While the lengthening capabilities are undeniably impressive, the formula's tendency to smudge and flake throughout the day makes it a difficult daily staple.

46%positive

V1 📕67%♪45%154 voices

"Mascara that i like to use is this benefit magnet one."

Whispered by Janet Mock · ~4 years ago

Shop at benefit →📦 Amazon

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

Janet Mock

actress

"Mascara that i like to use is this benefit magnet one."

— Janet Mock, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

67%

😊 Positive

11%

💬 Neutral

22%

👎 Negative

While many users praise the mascara for its impressive lengthening and lifting effects without clumping, others criticize it for severe smudging and dismiss the 'magnetic' technology as a marketing gimmick.

😊

纤长黑科技...轻松画出纤长惊艳的睫毛，就真的眼看着越涂越长

Lengthening black technology... easily creates stunning long lashes; you can literally see them getting longer as you apply.

👎

贝玲妃睫毛膏一生黑...晕得超厉害...直接晕出个眼睑下至

Hate Benefit mascara for life... it smudges so badly... it literally smudged into a fake lower eyelid look.

👎

帮大家拔草排雷...膏体吸住缝衣针这件事...那是因为膏体把针给黏住了

Helping everyone avoid this trap... as for the paste attracting a needle... it's just because the paste stuck to the needle.

💬

主要效果是卷翘+浓密，不会苍蝇腿的，刷下睫毛有点晕

The main effects are curling and volume without clumping, but it smudges a bit on the lower lashes.

See all 9 posts on Rednote →

45%

😊 Positive

20%

💬 Neutral

35%

👎 Negative

Users are divided on the Benefit They're Real! Magnet mascara; while many praise its extreme lengthening and lifting effects, others report significant issues with flaking, smudging, and difficulty with application.

😊

The new @benefitcosmetics They’re Real Magnet mascara most definitely brought my lashes to extreme lengths! Wow!

👎

Okay but how do you get it to stop flaking off during the day? I’ve tried everything.

👎

This smudges so badly under my eyes

😊

I think the magnets worked. I still question the safety and the whole gimmick aspect of magnetic anything near your eyes. But overall, this is a really good mascara.

😊

It is actually a great product. Made mine look longer than they naturally are. Highly recommend, 5/5 stars.