Name: They're Real! Xtreme Precision Liner
Brand: benefit
Rating: 3.8 (25 reviews)

The whisper

A resilient liquid liner that stays the course

Praised for its impressive longevity and precision, this formula holds up against water and daily wear. While most find it indispensable, some users note the brown shade lacks necessary depth.

75%loved

V3 📕71%♪75%136 voices

"this is the benefit they're real uh pursue Precision liner"

Whispered by Madelyn Cline · ~3 years ago

Shop at benefit →📦 Amazon

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

Tate McRae

singer

"I'm going to go in with this benefit eyeliner"

— Tate McRae, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

Madelyn Cline

actress

"this is the benefit they're real uh pursue Precision liner"

— Madelyn Cline, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

Kendall Jenner & others

"I'm going to go in with this benefit eyeliner doing a winged eyeliner."

— Kendall Jenner & others, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

71%

😊 Positive

29%

💬 Neutral

👎 Negative

Users highly praise the Benefit Roller Liner for its precision and long-lasting formula, often describing it as the best eyeliner from the brand. It is particularly noted for its ability to create fine lines and its resistance to smudging.

😊

能开眼角的极细眼线液笔

An ultra-fine liquid eyeliner that can define the inner corners of the eyes.

😊

至今用过最好的benefit眼线笔

The best Benefit eyeliner I've used so far.

😊

守护最好用的眼线笔，手皮都搓掉了也没掉

Protecting the best eyeliner; it didn't come off even after rubbing my skin off.

😊

随缘po北美超级好用的眼线笔

Randomly posting about a super useful eyeliner from North America.

See all 7 posts on Rednote →

75%

😊 Positive

10%

💬 Neutral

15%

👎 Negative

Users frequently praise the eyeliner for its precise 0.1mm brush tip, deep black pigment, and long-lasting waterproof formula, though some report issues with the product drying out quickly or inconsistent performance in the brown shade.

😊

I receive this complimentary from benifits/Influenster to review and let me tell you IT IS GREAT! So dark, lasted all day, easy to use…

😊

I really love the benefit one seriously stays on! It’s like 48 hour wear seriously

👎

I have both, Ive had the nyx one for three years it still works like a dream, but the xtreme SUCKS i havent even had it for two months and its dead

👎

The brown is too light for me I do like brown liners but this one is a pass. The concept and packaging is super cute tho

😊

At work, my face does get splashed with water pretty often. I don't really worry about my eyeliner when I'm using this one. And I'm not even trying to be a sellout. Like, it's just, it's genuinely good.