Charlotte Tilbury

Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Mat Lipstick in Independent

The whisper
A sensory indulgence with a polarizing texture

While the scent and brightening effect earn high praise, the occasional grittiness and shade inconsistency leave some users divided.

75%loved
V175%62 voices
"I do like lip liner I think also because you can over line them but it does keep the lipstick in place this is the shade independent."
Whispered by Phoebe Tonkin · ~3 years ago
Shop at Charlotte Tilbury →
Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

Phoebe Tonkin
Phoebe Tonkin
actress
"I do like lip liner I think also because you can over line them but it does keep the lipstick in place this is the shade independent."
— Phoebe Tonkin, Vogue Beauty Secrets
4:59
Watch clip
75%
😊 Positive
10%
💬 Neutral
15%
👎 Negative
Users generally praise the Charlotte Tilbury and Gucci lipsticks for their elegant finish and color payoff, though some express frustration over product reformulations, gritty textures, or the lack of shade information in tutorials.
👎
I love icon baby but I’m upset it’s a bit gritty on the lips 🙃
👎
Charlotte tilbury lipsticks are too light I don’t like them ,, best lipsticks are Mac and maybilline and elf lipsticks
😊
Made my teeth look so white 😍
😊
Il sent tellement bon ce rouge à lèvres-là.
This lipstick smells so good.
😊
Why the Charlotte Tilbury Matte Revolution is a total MUST-HAVE! ✨💄

What readers think

Loading comments…

Buy at Charlotte Tilbury