Name: Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara
Brand: Charlotte Tilbury
Rating: 2.2 (29 reviews)

The whisper

A polarizing wand that divides on performance

While some praise the precise applicator and separation, the formula is plagued by reports of significant smudging and lash drooping for many users.

43%positive

V2 📕25%♪45%99 voices

"this is my most recent favorite push-up lashes like Charlotte Tilbury"

Whispered by Kim Petras · ~3 years ago

Shop at Charlotte Tilbury →💄 Ulta Beauty 📦 Amazon

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

Alia Bhatt

actress

"Charlotte Tilbury, pillow talk."

— Alia Bhatt, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

Kim Petras

singer

"this is my most recent favorite push-up lashes like Charlotte Tilbury"

— Kim Petras, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

25%

😊 Positive

25%

💬 Neutral

50%

👎 Negative

While users appreciate the high-quality packaging and initial curling effects, the product is heavily criticized for severe smudging and creating 'panda eyes' shortly after application.

😊

几乎不会有苍蝇腿的问题...卷翘的话搭配睫毛夹我觉得保持的不错

There are almost no fly legs... with a lash curler, I think the curl holds up well.

😊

这一支CT惊艳到我了！图片中是没有夹睫毛只在专柜刷了一层的效果！

This CT one amazed me! The photo shows the effect of just one coat without using a lash curler!

👎

我晕，是真晕...关键是全部都没粘我睫毛上，都在我眼睑上了

It smudges, it really smudges... the key is none of it stayed on my lashes, it's all on my eyelids.

👎

我用几次就会晕几次...下眼睑那里都是黑的全晕染了

It smudges every time I use it... the lower eyelid area is all black and completely smudged.

💬

刷头比较平...纤长浓密型的，不会有苍蝇腿，不会踏，但要根根分明很困难

The brush head is quite flat... it's lengthening and volumizing, no fly legs, doesn't collapse, but it's hard to get distinct lashes.

See all 9 posts on Rednote →

45%

😊 Positive

15%

💬 Neutral

40%

👎 Negative

Users are divided on the mascara; fans praise its ability to separate, lengthen, and provide a natural look, while critics frequently report issues with smudging, transfer, and the product arriving dried out.

👎

I work at Mecca and I never recommend, every says it transfers and smudges

😊

So I cannot begin to express to you guys how good this mascara is. This is the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push-Up Lashes. Look at how good my lashes look.

👎

Save your money, this did nothing for me. I got this sample for free, for me it didn't live up to the claims. It smudged a lot.

👎

It also dropped my lashes too. I loved the wand but my lashes looked like straight daggers

😊

This applicator, the way it grabs lashes, it separates them really beautifully, keeping it really natural look.