Name: Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner
Brand: Essence
Rating: 3.8 (18 reviews)

The whisper

A high-performance formula hampered by frustrating design

75%loved

1 ♪75%134 voices

"I'm going to go in with the stay and play gel eyeliner in the shade very ber"

Whispered by KathleenLights · ~2 years ago

Shop at Essence →💄 Ulta Beauty

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

KathleenLights

1 mention about this product

Mixed

FULL FACE OF DRUGSTORE MAKEUP - Best Of Essence!! · ~2 years ago

"I'm going to go in with the stay and play gel eyeliner in the shade very ber"

75%

😊 Positive

10%

💬 Neutral

15%

👎 Negative

Users generally praise the Essence Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner for its affordability, creamy texture, and long-lasting pigment, though many struggle significantly with how to sharpen the pencil packaging.

😊

Essence eyeliner is great! Doesn’t smear or budge! 🔥

👎

Very difficult to sharpen, and they don't make a sharpener for it. Any suggestions?

😊

Love, love, love them because they glide on so well. It stays on all day.

👎

The tip fell off, so I went to sharpen it. And can someone explain to me why it's hollow on the inside and there's literally no product?

😊

Best eyeliner I’ve ever used!

Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner

Who’s talking about it

What readers think

Other products you might like