MAC

Lip Pencil

Lip Pencil
The whisper
A nostalgic staple with a fragile, temperamental edge

While long-time devotees cherish the classic shades for their archival accuracy, the formula's structural integrity remains a point of contention for modern users.

65%favored
1V265%178 voices
"the last thing I bought in the states it was a lip liner from Mac"
Whispered by Huh Yunjin · ~2 years ago
Shop at MAC →💄 Ulta Beauty📦 Amazon
Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

KathleenLights
1 mention about this product
Recommends
14:46
MY SPRING OBSESSIONS - Books, Makeup, Polish + Perfume · 3mo ago
"I have it on top of MAC Spice mixed with Alamar Cosmetics birthday suit."
Huh Yunjin
Huh Yunjin
singer
"the last thing I bought in the states it was a lip liner from Mac"
— Huh Yunjin, Vogue Beauty Secrets
8:21
Watch clip
Carlacia Grant
Carlacia Grant
actress
"Mac lip liner."
— Carlacia Grant, Vogue Beauty Secrets
8:22
Watch clip
65%
😊 Positive
10%
💬 Neutral
25%
👎 Negative
Users highly praise the iconic shade range and pigmentation of MAC Lip Pencils, though many express frustration over recent formula changes, perceived shifts toward warmer tones, and issues with the pencils snapping during sharpening.
👎
Mac lip liner don’t last at all Nyx better n cheaper
👎
The modern one practically looks like terracotta in comparison! The old version is so much better!
😊
Cool Spice Lip Pencil from @MAC Cosmetics USA is so similar to the original 90's MAC Spice lipliner I loved and adored!
👎
I bought one of the lip liners like a few weeks ago. And, well, specifically, every time I keep sharpening it, it keeps snapping.
😊
The pencil is so buttery. And don't let me sharpen it. Don't let me sharpen it. It's over with.

What readers think

Loading comments…

Buy at MAC