Name: Maybelline Great Lash Big Washable Mascara, Blackest Black
Brand: MAYBELLINE NEW YORK
Rating: 3.2 (24 reviews)

Maybelline Great Lash Big Washable Mascara, Blackest Black

The whisper

A nostalgic staple that divides opinion

While some swear by its precise brush and reliable, long-wearing finish for a natural look, others find the formula irritating or simply underwhelming compared to newer alternatives.

64%favored

V1 📕50%♪65%130 voices

"my favorite part mascara I mix these two I use great lash every high schooler knows what this is"

Whispered by Maxine Ashley · ~8 years ago

📦 Amazon

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

Maxine Ashley

singer

"my favorite part mascara I mix these two I use great lash every high schooler knows what this is"

— Maxine Ashley, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

50%

😊 Positive

17%

💬 Neutral

33%

👎 Negative

Users are polarized regarding the Maybelline Sky High mascara; while some recommend it as a smudge-proof essential, others strongly advise against it, labeling it a product to avoid.

😊

不晕染睫毛膏推荐/美宝莲

Smudge-proof mascara recommendation/Maybelline

👎

别用这个会变得不幸

Don't use this, it will make you unhappy

💬

美宝莲睫毛膏撑得高和冲天桥怎么选？

Maybelline Mascara: Sky High vs. Lash Sensational? How to choose?

👎

避雷❌美宝莲睫毛膏

Avoid/Thunderbolt ❌ Maybelline Mascara

See all 6 posts on Rednote →

65%

😊 Positive

15%

💬 Neutral

20%

👎 Negative

Users frequently describe this mascara as an iconic, budget-friendly, and nostalgic "OG" product, though opinions are divided on its performance compared to modern alternatives. While many praise its natural look and ease of use, some users report issues with allergic reactions, clumping, or difficulty with removal.

😊

I absolutely love wearing this mascara on a night out. The small brush makes applying so easy and adds length and volume to every single lash.

👎

eso 🥺🥺🥺 fue lo peor que yo pude comprar en mi vida en mi caso me dio alergia se me hincharon los ojos como que abejas me hubiesen picado

That was the worst thing I could have bought in my life; in my case, it gave me an allergy and my eyes swelled up as if bees had stung me.

😊

Doesn’t flake for at least 24 hours. Stays all days and doesn’t transfer

👎

Meh, I’m with you, there are better ones out there!

😊

I’ve tried cover girl, L’Oréal and others, this is the best for a beautiful, natural, simple look, period 💯