Name: SLICK WATERLINE EYE PENCIL
Brand: Melt
Rating: 4.2 (18 reviews)

The whisper

Creamy, pigmented, but occasionally drifts from the waterline

85%loved

1 ♪85%134 voices

"And the Melt Cosmetics Slick Waterline eyeliner is the best."

Whispered by KathleenLights · 6mo ago

Shop at Melt →

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

KathleenLights

1 mention about this product

Recommends

BEST PRODUCTS OF THE YEAR! 2025 FAVORITES · 6mo ago

"And the Melt Cosmetics Slick Waterline eyeliner is the best."

85%

😊 Positive

💬 Neutral

10%

👎 Negative

Users consistently praise the Melt Slick Waterline Eye Pencil for its buttery, smooth application, high pigmentation, and ease of blending for smoky eye looks. While most find it to be a staple product, a small subset of users expressed concerns regarding its longevity on the waterline throughout the day.

😊

Best pencils ever!!!!!

👎

Goes on so well and so smooth but for the waterline, they don’t stay the best.

😊

Blends like butter 🖤

😊

It applies super creamy and stays put for hours

😊

Their everything is sooooo PIGMENTED!!! Literally EVERY dang product they come out with is pigmented tha house!!!🖤