Who’s talking about it
Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.
KathleenLights
Recommends
10:25
"if you still have your NYX jumbo eye pencil and milk bust that out for this"
75%
😊 Positive
10%
💬 Neutral
15%
👎 Negative
Users widely consider the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk an iconic, affordable staple for brightening the waterline, highlighting, and serving as a pigmented eyeshadow base. While many praise its versatility and creamy texture, some users report issues with longevity, patchiness, or difficulty sharpening the pencil.
😊
It's the most opaque white that I found in an eyeliner, and it's very easy to apply.
👎
I tried to use it on my water line and it just looks patchy/chalky
😊
I use it as a base for eyeshadow and as a base for when I do white eyeshadow so it's more pigmented
👎
I got it too, but it comes off so easily
😊
An oldie but a goodie
Loading comments…