Name: ColorStay™ Eyeliner
Brand: REVLON
Rating: 3.8 (22 reviews)

The whisper

A polarizing staple that defies and disappoints

While many swear by its legendary staying power for long days, others find the formula inconsistent and difficult to apply. It remains a divisive choice that either performs perfectly or fails entirely.

75%loved

1 V1 📕67%♪75%182 voices

"what does this color say this is a Colorstay eyeliner and i don't use it on my eyes i use it on my mole"

Whispered by Ashley Graham · ~6 years ago

Shop at REVLON →💄 Ulta Beauty 📦 Amazon

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

KathleenLights

1 mention about this product

Mixed

BIRTHDAY MAKEUP GET READY WITH ME · ~2 years ago

"this is the Revlon ColorStay black eyeliner."

Ashley Graham

model

"what does this color say this is a Colorstay eyeliner and i don't use it on my eyes i use it on my mole"

— Ashley Graham, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

67%

😊 Positive

💬 Neutral

33%

👎 Negative

Users are divided on the Revlon ColorStay eyeliner; while some appreciate its waterproof formula and beginner-friendly features, others report severe smudging and a fragile lead.

👎

一到下午，完全就是熊猫眼啊喂！...一不小心画重一点笔芯会容易断

By the afternoon, it's a total panda eye! ...If you draw a bit too hard, the lead breaks easily.

😊

持久不脱妆，平价好物一生推哦，学生党钱包伤不起啊

Long-lasting and smudge-proof, a budget-friendly must-have for life; students' wallets can't afford expensive stuff.

😊

真正的技术防水，水洗不掉，需要用专业的卸妆产品。

Truly waterproof technology, won't wash off with water, requires professional makeup remover.

😊

这个自动笔芯很方便，还自带小卷笔槽，我入的是201黑色，非常百搭

This automatic lead is very convenient and comes with a small sharpener; I got 201 Black, which is very versatile.

75%

😊 Positive

10%

💬 Neutral

15%

👎 Negative

TikTok users frequently praise the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner for its long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof performance, often highlighting its ease of use for beginners. While many consider it a reliable drugstore staple, a minority of users report issues with smudging or difficulty in application.

😊

This eyeliner is of larga duración and se mantiene hasta por 24 horas. No se corre ni se desvanece.

This eyeliner is long-lasting and stays on for up to 24 hours. It doesn't smudge or fade.

👎

The worst eyeliner i’ve tried lol in 2 hours it’s almost completely off

😊

I just found the legit smudge-proof, sweat-proof, water-proof eyeliner pencil and it’s the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner.

👎

i tried the revlon colorstay pencil in charcoal and oh my god it was so bad. it barely applied to my eyelids.

👎

these suck everyone. smudge and are not waterproof or lasting