Name: Eye Want You Mascara in Clean Black
Brand: Westman Atelier
Rating: 2.8 (27 reviews)

The whisper

A polarizing lash enhancer that divides its audience

While some find the formula creates a flawless, false-lash effect, others struggle with significant smudging and a steep price point. It remains a divisive choice for those with oily lids.

54%favored

V2 📕38%♪55%159 voices

"Read Clark another Westman thing."

Whispered by Jennifer Garner · ~2 years ago

Shop at Westman Atelier →📦 Amazon

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

Samara Weaving

actress

"this mascara by West Nota I have been hunting for the perfect mascara for so long"

— Samara Weaving, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

Jennifer Garner

actress

"Read Clark another Westman thing."

— Jennifer Garner, Vogue Beauty Secrets

Watch clip

38%

😊 Positive

37%

💬 Neutral

25%

👎 Negative

Users are polarized on the Westman Atelier Eye Love You Mascara; while some praise it for creating a natural, curled 'clean girl' look, others find it difficult to use and poor value for the price.

👎

Westman Atelier|美则美矣的难用合集

Westman Atelier | A collection of products that are beautiful but hard to use

😊

从没想过我会再次爱上睫毛膏…

Never thought I would fall in love with mascara again...

👎

到底是谁说它好用的啊！

Who on earth said this was good?!

😊

10s刷出超绝妈生卷翘睫毛

Brushing out amazing natural curled lashes in 10s

😊

🇺🇸sephora白女姐姐推荐的睫毛膏是真好用

The mascara recommended by the Sephora girl is really good

See all 8 posts on Rednote →

55%

😊 Positive

15%

💬 Neutral

30%

👎 Negative

Users frequently praise the mascara for its aesthetic packaging and natural, fluttery lash effect, though many express significant hesitation regarding its high price point and reports of smudging on oily lids.

😊

The Westman Atelier mascara is UNMATCHED and has been the only mascara that I've worn for the last 6 months

👎

Its pretty yes. But €48 for a mascara is not my thing

👎

GUYS the brown one smudges so bad!!!!! If u have even slightly oily lids dont bother

😊

it’s buildable and it looks like i have falsies on

👎

Expensive brand for smearing