Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

16:38
What’s in my everyday makeup bag?! · ~4 years ago
"this is the ill machias and carly bible waterproof lip liner in the shade ai oh my god i love this"
4 more videos from KathleenLights→
Users highly praise the IL MAKIAGE Carli Bybel lip liner as a 'holy grail' product, often stocking up on it and finding it difficult to replace with even high-end alternatives. It is frequently featured as a top choice for nude lip looks and reliable North American makeup.
😊
人生挚爱唇线笔
Life's favorite lip liner
😊
找个最爱唇线笔贵替咋就那么难
Why is it so hard to find a high-end dupe for my favorite lip liner
😊
唇线笔用一囤一的含金量🈶
The value of using one and stocking up on one lip liner
😊
最近入手的🇺🇸北美彩妆居然每个都不错!
The North American makeup I recently bought is actually all quite good!
See all 6 posts on Rednote →
Users frequently praise the IL MAKIAGE x Carli Bybel lip products for their smooth application, beautiful color payoff, and ability to create perfect neutral lip combinations. While the collection is highly desired, some users express frustration regarding product availability and one user noted a dislike for the glittery texture of the lip gloss.
😊
Oh it feels so soft and it's so smooth going on your lips. Also love the color isn't very harsh.
👎
Hated the lipgloss it was too glittery 🥵😩 it’s hard to get rid of
😊
I CANT GET OVER HOW WELL THE LINER & LIPSTICK MATCH!
💬
Gorgeous! I am dying for the lipstick & lipliner, but they r no more.
Loading comments…