Name: Artist Color Pencil Extreme
Brand: MAKE UP FOR EVER
Rating: 3.8 (17 reviews)

The whisper

A long-wearing staple with a temperamental edge

Reliable for its impressive longevity and staying power, the formula earns high praise for performance. However, users find the pencil frustrating to sharpen and note slight inconsistencies in shade.

75%loved

2 ♪75%169 voices

"and now they have their extreme version of it which is supposed to be a lot more longwearing... I really really like it."

Whispered by KathleenLights · 1y ago

Shop at MAKE UP FOR EVER →📦 Amazon 🌸 YesStyle

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

From Head To Toe

2 mentions about this product

Recommends

HOLY GRAILS 2025/2026 | The Best Beauty Products of the Year · 5mo ago

"I really like this one from Makeup Forever. I feel like I talk about this every time... Artist Color Pencil Extreme."

1 more video from From Head To Toe→

2025 SEPHORA SAVINGS EVENT SALE Recommendations | Jen C · 6mo ago

"I'm sure everybody and their mom has already been talking about the Makeup Forever pencil... This is the Artist Color Pencil Extreme."

KathleenLights

1 mention about this product

Recommends

October Favorites - Makeup, Perfumes, Books!!! · 1y ago

"and now they have their extreme version of it which is supposed to be a lot more longwearing... I really really like it."

75%

😊 Positive

10%

💬 Neutral

15%

👎 Negative

Users generally praise the product for its intense pigment, creamy texture, and long-lasting waterproof performance, though many express frustration regarding the difficulty of sharpening the pencils.

😊

I love the new extreme pencils- same colors and they don’t BUDGE, but I will say, not the easiest to sharpen and started crumbling on me some.

👎

I tried to do it with a normal sharpener and it broke the whole beak, it didn't work

😊

It’s so good! I was wearing it at dinner and someone who sat next to me said they noticed it stayed on throughout the whole meal

😊

I’d say 10 hours is pretty good without any touch-ups.

👎

I feel like they’re not the same shades tho