Name: Artist Color Pencil Extreme
Brand: MAKE UP FOR EVER
Rating: 3.8 (25 reviews)

The whisper

A long-wearing staple with a temperamental edge

73%loved

"and now they have their extreme version of it which is supposed to be a lot more longwearing... I really really like it."

Whispered by KathleenLights · 1y ago

Affiliate links — recommendations stay independent.

Who’s talking about it

Grouped by source and by who’s talking — not by individual videos.

From Head To Toe

2 mentions about this product

Recommends

2025 SEPHORA SAVINGS EVENT SALE Recommendations | Jen Chae · 8mo ago

"I'm sure everybody and their mom has already been talking about the Makeup Forever pencil... This is the Artist Color Pencil Extreme."

1 more video from From Head To Toe→

HOLY GRAILS 2025/2026 | The Best Beauty Products of the · 6mo ago

"I really like this one from Makeup Forever. I feel like I talk about this every time... Artist Color Pencil Extreme."

KathleenLights

1 mention about this product

Recommends

October Favorites - Makeup, Perfumes, Books!!! · 1y ago

"and now they have their extreme version of it which is supposed to be a lot more longwearing... I really really like it."

38%

😊 Positive

62%

💬 Neutral

👎 Negative

Users generally praise the MAKE UP FOR EVER Artist Color Pencil for its smooth texture and versatility across different facial features, though some note its premium pricing.

😊

MUST HAVE LIP LINERS 必须有唇线笔

MUST HAVE LIP LINERS.

😊

彩色油画棒上脸真的丝滑

The colored oil painting sticks are really smooth on the face.

😊

我感觉还蛮好用的价格也不算便宜

I feel it's quite good to use, and the price isn't cheap either.

💬

MUFE 新品 Artist Color Pencil 全试色

Full swatches of the new MUFE Artist Color Pencil.

See all 8 posts on Rednote →

75%

😊 Positive

10%

💬 Neutral

15%

👎 Negative

Users generally praise the product for its intense pigment, creamy texture, and long-lasting waterproof performance, though many express frustration regarding the difficulty of sharpening the pencils.

😊

I love the new extreme pencils- same colors and they don’t BUDGE, but I will say, not the easiest to sharpen and started crumbling on me some.

👎

I tried to do it with a normal sharpener and it broke the whole beak, it didn't work

😊

It’s so good! I was wearing it at dinner and someone who sat next to me said they noticed it stayed on throughout the whole meal

😊

I’d say 10 hours is pretty good without any touch-ups.

👎

I feel like they’re not the same shades tho